01
Required structure
A note records what the person tried, what worked, what got in the way and one change they would make. “I could not access the product” is a valid, useful note. Relationships with the maker must be disclosed; the disclosure is kept private.
02
Moderation
A person checks every note for a genuine attempt, relevance, safety and privacy. Moderation does not require a favourable opinion. Generic praise, unrelated promotion and fabricated use are rejected, and rejected notes do not count toward a feedback round.
03
Feedback rounds
Round assignments are made by a person. Nobody is assigned their own project or a colleague’s, and the same pair is not reused without a reason. Makers are told only after a note is approved.
04
Limits
Feedback notes are not quality, accessibility, performance, legal, medical, financial, privacy or security audits. A note may miss defects. There are no star ratings, credits or paid reviews.